Wednesday, April 16, 2025
I woke up early last night and only dozed intermittently for the rest of the night. My spirits were raised. I have no idea why. I can only be grateful that I wasn't caught in grief. I hadn't even enjoyed writing during this period. That's pretty bad. I love putting thoughts into words.
Many years ago, in the 1980s, I had a twelve-year-old student named Matthew. One day, I gave him a ride to the shopping center to meet his mother. He asked, 'Do you like to talk?" I said, "Yes." He said, "I love to talk." After a brief silence, I said, "I love to think." He followed with, "Yeah. Think about talking." We then shared how people often told us to shut up. That was at least forty years ago. I wonder what became of Matthew.
There was another incident with him. His mom had come to pick him up. We chatted for a minute. Matthew asked me a personal question. His mom told him he was rude. I said I asked personal questions. She said, "But you're sensitive.' I assured her I hadn't been at twelve. My sensitivity was learned through experience and failure to be sensitive. My guess is Matthew remembers those moments as much as I do.
As I lay in bed before rising, I had some thoughts. Yvette showed me her rash. Holy cow! She was covered with redness and bumps from her ribs down to her hips. I just got a quick glimpse. As I lay in bed, I remembered it was only on the left side of her body, from the front midline to the back. That could be shingles. I was anxious to speak to her. When I got hold of her, she told me she had thought of it. The rash wasn't as painful as shingles usually are. I had shingles twice: the first time, I was twelve, and the second time, I was sixty. In the first bout, it hurt when I scratched it. That's how my parents figured out it wasn't just any rash. Other than that, there was no pain either time. Shingles is infamous for its pain because when it is painful, it is very painful.
Yvette said there was no pain, not even when she gave in to the temptation to scratch. There were other counterindications. I suggested she get a shingles vaccination as soon as possible. I never had any residual effects from the outbreaks, but I understand they can be life-altering.
Mama K texted me first thing in the morning to let me know the girls would be busy today and couldn't meet with me. She is much better at communicating and supporting my work with the girls than she used to be. Recently, I commented that she hadn't supported it as much at first because she held out no hope for the Twins. Since Twin A is reading on grade level and doing reasonably well in math, she's changed her tune.
I had an appointment with fifth-grade GV at 1:30. I was available at that hour because the Twins had canceled. We continued working on math. He aced the addition of fractions with mixed denominators. He got an answer of 1 and 3/15 but didn't understand he had to reduce the fraction to its lowest terms. I planned to review that in our next session.
I asked if he wanted to work on multiplication of fractions. He said no, he wanted to work on his multiplication facts. He didn't know how to multiply 6 x 9=. I told him to find the nearest multiplication fact he knew and use it to add and subtract from there. I gave him 6 x 10=. He didn't have a clue. I had to show him the pattern. Whenever I showed him another pattern, he would say, "Cool!" However, he didn't look for patterns on his own. I would have to teach him to do it.
I drew a number line and wrote out the 6 times table. He said he used that idea when finding the lowest common denominator, but not to solve multiplication problems without fractions. I can see why he has a low mark for his complex thinking skills.
I signed on at 4:20 for my session with LG. I had forgotten his mom said we had to do it earlier because there was an event at the school at 5 pm. I still had one appointment with him the next day..
I finally had fifth-grade ZN at the end of the day. I told him he had a fantastic memory for spelling, but not when it came to reading words. I thought of a way he could transfer his good spelling skills to reading. I had him look at each word of the first 50 words on the Fry Sight word list, then, using his index finger, 'write/spell' the word on a textured surface. He aced every one of the first 25 and got 23 out of the second 25. Then, I had him read and 'spell' every word in the passage he had spelled in our last session. Again, he read every word accurately. I may be on to something, or it may just be a fluke. We'll see.
While the Orton-Gillingham instructor focused on phonics, I had a background in cognition and neuroscience, which was not readily available at that time. Educators focused on presenting information without considering students' cognitive and emotional needs.
I started watching A Remarkable Place to Die on Netflix. I'm enjoying the production, but it's worthwhile watching for the views. It takes place somewhere in Australia.
Because GV's teacher said nothing other than she had done some work with him before I started working with him, it left me wondering what she thought of his improvement. Did she think I had any impact, or did she believe it was all her work? Believe it or not, education is a very competitive field. We're rarely sure of our impact on our students. We can be sure we put together a good lesson, but we cannot know how it impacted our students. Did she think the school had done it all, that she had done it all, and his family was wasting their time and money on me? Her silence left me feeling uncomfortable.
I commented about the schools not allowing volunteers to help the children. The school has bought into the Success for All program, which insists the students should not be exposed to any other method. GV's teacher agreed it was a ridiculous proposition. While the program is a good one, no one approach will always address the needs of all the children. One has to wonder why a company or a school district would adopt such an extreme stance.
I worked with Shelly today. I worked myself into a state of agitation again. Damn! We need to deal with the human condition of inner rage when we don't get what we want. It comes out one way or another. We have to learn to live with it. I help others face it. It's such an unpleasant emotion. I love being loving, kinship-love a la Father Boyle of the Homeboys Industries instead of the compassionate form of love. Compassion often separates us from others. It says I'm okay, but you're not. Kinship acknowledges we're all in the same boat.
I pulled up an Audible mystery that captivated me for the whole day. It's well written and well read: Tim Sullivan's The Patient. That was my day.
I ran into Fifth grade GV's homeroom teacher this morning. I hadn't seen her for about a year. I've been walking later, and she had stopped running in my neighborhood regularly. First, she caught me up on the developments in her personal life. She had been in the process of leaving her husband, the father of her children, last year. They had been in couples counseling forever, and nothing had changed. She had filed for divorce and started dating again. She fell in love. She said she never thought she could feel that way about someone. They got married shortly after her divorce was finalized. She had moved to the other side of Kaiminani, and she and her new husband were looking for another place to live.
She told me she was fifth-grade GV's homeroom teacher. I would love to have had feedback from her, but she felt she was required to respect his privacy; she could face charges if she didn't. I didn't feel quite as confined. I don't talk about my clients publicly, except on the updates where I don't use their names. Writing about them serves two purposes. It helps me think through their issues and how to resolve them. Second, I believe I have worthwhile insights into teaching, and it's a way to put my ideas out there.
I shared that GV had made significant improvement in his word recognition and fluency skills. He still got stuck on multi-syllable words, primarily because he couldn't tolerate not understanding the meaninglessness of the individual syllables. They usually have none.
In phonics training, some programs have students work on nonsense syllables. The Whole Language folks find that a waste of time or worse. However, that's what readers encounter in multi-syllable words and nonsense syllables. GV has a low tolerance for things that don't make immediate sense. It's perhaps the biggest obstacle to his learning. You need to have a tolerance for not knowing to be a good learner and producer. Having a high tolerance for failure is an essential key to success. His teacher only commented that his low tolerance for uncertainty also impacts his social relationships.
GV had made substantial improvements in spelling, but he couldn't sustain it when writing. The neurological load when composing, writing what he composes (versus dictating), and spelling is too much. I realize teachers have marveled about students doing well on spelling tests but not when they write. It's now clear to me why that happens. I teach spelling by dictating whole paragraphs. They have the opportunity to practice writing the little words as well as the big ones. Spelling tests these days include dictated sentences, but only in the context of a test. Testing is not a good way to teach. It only identifies what the student has trouble with. I have never seen a teacher teach students how to study spelling. It's as if everyone should know what to do. I learned my study skills from my dad. If parents don't know more than their children do, the kids sink. This may explain the heavy correlation between Socioeconomic status (SES) and student performance.
I'm working on comprehension with GV now, too. He dismisses information as incorrect when he disagrees with it and, therefore, gets the wrong answer. He doesn't know the difference between comprehension and agreement. Many of the kids I work with have this problem, and I have to revisit it repeatedly.
In his writing, I find his sentences awkward. The method I use, having the students dictate their stories to me, significantly impacts their language development because they hear me modeling how to express their ideas. I started using this method without considering the consequences other than creating a well-written story based on the student's ideas. I was as surprised as everyone else about the impact on their verbal expression skills, both oral and written. I have recently incorporated using Grammarly with them to correct their work (and my typing) for clarity. Grammarly is an impersonal evaluator. Using it on my updates has improved the quality of my writing. When using it with students, they can choose whether or not to use Grammarly's suggestion. I can chime in if I think their manner of expression is unclear. I rarely do. What I do with many students is write their stories myself, using their sketchy input. That's where I have to start with some kids. Then, slowly, they start giving me whole sentences.
Because GV's teacher said nothing other than she had done some work with him before I started working with him, it left me wondering what she thought of his improvement. Did she think I had any impact, or did she believe it was all her work? Believe it or not, education is a very competitive field. We're rarely sure of our impact on our students. We can be sure we put together a good lesson, but we cannot know how it impacted our students. Did she think the school had done it all, that she had done it all, and his family was wasting their time and money on me? Her silence left me feeling uncomfortable.
I commented about the schools not allowing volunteers to help the children. The school has bought into the Success for All program, which insists the students should not be exposed to any other method. GV's teacher agreed it was a ridiculous proposition. While the program is a good one, no one approach will always address the needs of all the children. One has to wonder why a company or a school district would adopt such an extreme stance.
I worked with Shelly today. I worked myself into a state of agitation again. Damn! We need to deal with the human condition of inner rage when we don't get what we want. It comes out one way or another. We have to learn to live with it. I help others face it. It's such an unpleasant emotion. I love being loving, kinship-love a la Father Boyle of the Homeboys Industries instead of the compassionate form of love. Compassion often separates us from others. It says I'm okay, but you're not. Kinship acknowledges we're all in the same boat.
I pulled up an Audible mystery that captivated me for the whole day. It's well-written and well read: Tim Sullivan's The Patient. That was my day.